As IPL 2025 approaches, teams are gearing up for the retention window, which closes on 31st October 2024. Mumbai Indians (MI), one of the most successful franchises in IPL history, must carefully evaluate which players to retain as they can retain a maximum of six players. This decision will have a significant impact on their success in the upcoming season. Let’s look at and examine the performances of two key players from IPL 2024 – Ishan Kishan and Tilak Varma – and determine who MI should retain based on their batting, bowling, and fielding capabilities.
Ishan Kishan’s IPL 2024 Performance
Ishan Kishan, known for his explosive batting at the top of the order, had an interesting season in IPL 2024. He scored 320 runs in 14 matches, with a strike rate of 148.83, showcasing his ability to play aggressive cricket. His highest score of 69 was a testament to his talent, but his average of 22.85 suggests inconsistency in converting starts into big scores. Ishan also smashed 35 fours and 16 sixes which shows his attacking mindset.
Ishan’s strike rate of 148.83 is a significant asset for MI. His ability to take on bowlers from the start of the innings sets the tone for the team. In the current T20 era, an aggressive opener who can make the powerplay overs count is invaluable. However, to be a strong contender for retention, Ishan Kishan will need to work on his average and conversion rate.
While Ishan’s primary role is with the bat, his fielding contributions cannot be overlooked. As a wicketkeeper-batsman, he brings added value with his safe hands behind the stumps. His work behind the stumps in IPL 2024 has been commendable where he has grabbed 9 catches.
Tilak Varma’s IPL 2024 Performance
Tilak Varma, the young sensation, had an outstanding IPL 2024 season. In 13 matches, Tilak scored an impressive 416 runs at an average of 41.60, significantly higher than Kishan’s. His highest score of 65 might not seem remarkable, but his consistency stands out. Unlike Ishan, Tilak has demonstrated the ability to perform consistently, crossing the 40-run mark multiple times, which is crucial for a middle-order batsman.
Tilak’s temperament, coupled with his ability to handle pressure, adds depth to the MI lineup. Though he hasn’t scored a century, his average of 41.60 indicates his reliability, especially in situations where Mumbai Indians may lose early wickets. He is the kind of player who can anchor the innings while allowing the more aggressive batsmen to play freely around him.
Consistency and maturity define Tilak Varma’s batting. His ability to adapt to match situations, whether accelerating the scoring or consolidating the innings, makes him ultra-dependable.
Tilak Varma has also contributed significantly in the field, taking 9 catches during the season. Fielding is an often-overlooked aspect, but with T20 margins being as tight as they are, every catch counts.
Whom Should Mumbai Indians Retain?
Given that Mumbai Indians can retain up to six players ahead of the 2025 IPL season, they must be strategic about who they choose. Based on their IPL 2024 performances, here’s why both Ishan Kishan and Tilak Varma should be considered for retention:
- Ishan Kishan – His explosiveness at the top of the order is crucial for MI, especially in the powerplay. His ability to clear the boundary regularly makes him a valuable asset, even though his inconsistency could be a concern. As a wicketkeeper-batsman, Ishan brings versatility to the squad, which is always a bonus in the T20 format.
- Tilak Varma – Tilak’s consistency with the bat, coupled with his ability to handle pressure in the middle order, makes him an essential part of MI’s plans for the future. His fielding and part-time bowling also provide added dimensions to his game, making him a strong candidate for retention.
Other Key Retention Considerations for MI
Apart from Ishan Kishan and Tilak Varma, Mumbai Indians will likely focus on retaining players like Suryakumar Yadav, Jasprit Bumrah, and Cameron Green, who form the backbone of the team in terms of batting and bowling. With only six slots available, MI must balance retaining both experienced players and young talent for the future.
